Court Papers Reveal Defense Strategy in Alexander Brothers Sex Trafficking Trial

Defense Attorneys Claim Witnesses Are Lying as Manhattan Sex Trafficking Case Advances

Attorneys representing three brothers at the center of one of New York’s most high-profile sex trafficking and rape cases say they plan to prove that many witnesses in the upcoming trial are lying, according to recent court filings.

The defendants — Oren, Tal, and Alon Alexander — are accused of orchestrating a pattern of sexual assaults and trafficking spanning nearly two decades, targeting dozens of women across New York City, Miami, and Los Angeles. The brothers, known for their success in the luxury real estate market, have been held without bail since their arrests and are expected to stand trial in Manhattan federal court beginning January 5, 2026.

Judge Valerie E. Caproni held a pretrial hearing this week to set evidentiary and procedural rules ahead of the proceedings. The trial could last up to six weeks, according to prosecutors, who say they intend to present testimony from more than 60 women who allege they were raped or sexually assaulted by at least one of the brothers.

Defense Lawyers Allege Witness Fabrications

In documents filed Thursday, the defense claimed that photographic and digital evidence — including text messages and photos — would demonstrate that many witnesses are lying or exaggerating their accounts.

Defense attorneys alleged that certain accusers “do not want to admit to the world that they consensually engaged in sexual activity with any of the Alexander brothers” and claimed that others are motivated by “monetary gain” or “current personal circumstances.”

The defense also requested permission to withhold some evidence until the last minute, arguing that the defendants are entitled to “confront witnesses with the element of surprise.” Prosecutors objected to this strategy, asserting that it could compromise trial fairness and the integrity of witness testimony.

Judge Caproni has not yet ruled on the defense’s request but indicated she might postpone the trial until May 2026 to ensure sufficient time to resolve pending legal issues.

Prosecutors Allege a Pattern of Exploitation and Control

Federal prosecutors allege that the Alexander brothers used their wealth, status, and influence in the luxury real estate industry to lure women into dangerous situations where they were raped, assaulted, or trafficked. The allegations stretch from 2002 to 2021 and involve victims from multiple states.

The prosecution has described the brothers as serial abusers who maintained power over victims through intimidation, manipulation, and coercion. Some women reportedly met the brothers through professional or social connections, while others were introduced through high-profile nightlife events in Manhattan and Miami.

In their filings, prosecutors asserted that the defendants’ wealth and social prominence enabled them to evade accountability for years, even as multiple allegations surfaced in private and public forums.

“These men used their financial resources and professional standing to exploit, silence, and control their victims,” said one federal official familiar with the case. “This trial represents a critical moment for survivors who have waited years to be heard.”

A High-Stakes Trial Drawing National Attention

The Alexander brothers rose to prominence as the founders of a multimillion-dollar luxury brokerage known for selling high-end real estate to celebrities and international investors. Oren and Tal Alexander gained further fame through their involvement in high-profile property deals in New York and Florida, making their eventual arrests a headline-grabbing scandal.

The case has drawn national attention for its similarities to prior high-profile sexual abuse prosecutions involving powerful men accused of systemic exploitation, including those of Harvey Weinstein and Jeffrey Epstein.

As the January trial date approaches, prosecutors are expected to present testimony from dozens of survivors, supported by digital evidence and corroborating witnesses. The defense, meanwhile, is expected to challenge the credibility of nearly every accuser, alleging inconsistencies and ulterior motives.

Survivors Seek Justice and Accountability

For many survivors, the Alexander case represents more than a criminal proceeding — it is an opportunity for long-awaited validation and accountability. Advocates say that the lengthy investigation and federal involvement underscore the seriousness of the charges and the broader societal problem of sexual abuse by powerful individuals.

“This case demonstrates how influence and privilege can be weaponized against victims,” said a legal advocate for survivors of sexual assault. “But it also shows that power can be challenged — and justice can still prevail.”

Survivors’ rights attorneys across New York are closely monitoring the case, emphasizing the importance of trauma-informed legal representation to ensure survivors are protected and empowered throughout the process.

Legal Advocacy for Survivors in New York

The upcoming trial also serves as a reminder of the vital role that experienced legal advocates play in protecting the rights of sexual abuse survivors. Thomas Giuffra, Esq., managing attorney of Survivors of Abuse NY, is among New York’s most trusted voices in representing survivors of sexual assault, exploitation, and institutional negligence.

“When survivors take on powerful defendants, they deserve to have the truth on their side and a team willing to fight for it,” said Thomas Giuffra, Esq. “Our firm stands with those who have the courage to speak out, no matter how influential the abuser may be.”

Standing Up Against Sexual Exploitation

As the Alexander brothers’ case moves toward trial, it stands as another critical moment in the broader movement against sexual abuse and human trafficking — one that challenges the culture of silence surrounding misconduct among the wealthy and well-connected.

For survivors seeking legal guidance in New York, Survivors of Abuse NY offers confidential consultations and dedicated representation to pursue justice and accountability through both civil and criminal legal avenues.

Source:

https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/new-york/articles/2025-11-06/court-papers-show-luxury-real-estate-brothers-hope-to-prove-witnesses-lie-at-sex-trafficking-trial